After two weeks off, (thank you, thank you very much) and seeing as I’m more than likely the last person to weigh in on the 2009 Winter Classic, all there is left to say is that myself (like you) watched from beginning to end with glee and massive enjoyment. The league could not have chosen two better teams to showcase the event than Detroit and Chicago. (Like Norm and Cliff, Jerry and George or even, Lord help us, Charles and Buddy. You’ll take either one by themselves, but it’s always better when their on at the same time) That Chicago is once again a mighty powerhouse is great for the league and listening to the crowd cheer during the “Star Spangled Banner” was reminiscent of the old Chicago Stadium. I really, really hope they bring that back for the playoffs. It really is a great sight.
Already people are debating where to go for next year. I won’t waste precious column time discussing things like this, that’s better left for a column during Canada Day weekend in between turns at the dunk tank. However, three golden match ups that absolutely must happen in the next three years:
Washington @ NY Rangers at New Yankee Stadium
Los Angeles @ Colorado at Coors Field
Montreal @ Boston at Fenway Park
There. I’ve said it. I’ll move onto something that is much more important: My own agenda.
There is still a problem with the NHL. That much we know. There is still no television deal with the US worth mentioning, there are still a large number of teams that are floundering and the recent economic struggles aren’t helping. (I’m almost positive it would be cheaper for me and three of my friends to rent a car, drive to Atlanta, purchase tickets, see the Thrashers lose 6-2, party with Atlanta girls and then drive home in the morning than to get tickets from a scalper for a Leafs game. Also less expensive: 8 balls and black market babies) Something must be done. Luckily I’ve developed a plan.
Now, keep in mind that this plan has about a 0% change of coming to fruition. The powers that be (ie the Commish) would never let this happen, which is fine. The league will eventually fix itself. Millions of dollars will be printed to save the garbage franchises from capsizing like the Titanic, and thousands of hockey fans in Detroit will eventually become interested to see Columbus at least three times a year. (Cue the monkeys…)
No friends, this is a plan that takes place entirely within the magical world of make believe, except that it’s entirely plausible, a sure fire money maker and would solve the biggest problems facing the league today. Alright, it might not create a huge television deal or scald Gary Bettman in the process, but I’m working on that ok? The first thing we need to do is address these problems, and it starts with the false notion that a historical rivalry is just as important now as it was 40 years ago.
First things first. We need to admit that the Toronto-Montreal experiment did not work. It just did not. Maple Leaf fans of today care very little about the Canadiens and Habs fans care very little about the Maple Leafs. That’s just the way it is. I don’t hate Montreal. I feel total indifference towards the Canadiens. The problem is that unless you were born prior to 1967, you never saw Montreal and Toronto battle much when you were growing up, so there’s no sense of hatred between the two teams. (Case in point, it’s been 30 years since the two clubs played in the playoffs, and, um, 42 since the Leafs won a game against them) I can understand from a historical standpoint that these two teams are supposed to be enemies but that doesn’t translate on the ice or in the stands. The fact of the matter is Leafs fans get up for Ottawa and Buffalo now. Habs fans really get up for Boston (and vice versa. Ask any Boston resident and they’ll tell you stories in which his friends Murph and Sully landed blows on some guy named Pierre after a Habs-Bruins playoff game) and they also get up for another team which always seems to beat them. Instead of trying to force old rivalries upon the public, we need to go back to simple rivalries of just a decade or two ago.
Secondly, this whole East vs West thing has to go. Is there really a reason we pit these two geographic areas against one another for the Stanley Cup? Is there any difference at all where the teams come from? Are the Kings supposed to hate the Devils because they play in different parts of the country? The NBA has always been East vs West for the championship so at least there’s historical value there. The NHL needs to go to where the NFL and MLB got it right: Two Conferences (bring back the names “Wales” & “Campbell”) with three divisions each: East, Central and West. Each one composed of five teams with geographical sensibilities but also and more importantly rivalry sensibilities.
Lastly, admit defeat and go looking for action elsewhere (like any sitcom that ever ended up on UPN). The NHL expansion boom of the 90s and early 2000s was not a complete failure everywhere. San Jose, Anaheim and (until people realized they’re still going nowhere) Columbus have healthy fan bases and sell out their arenas regularly. However Nashville, Florida and Atlanta are garbage dumps. Atlanta is the worst sports city perhaps on planet Earth and should become the first city to lose a professional sports team twice. Nashville has been the talk of moving from everywhere from Kansas City (a move that makes no sense from a hockey standpoint. Middle America belongs to the KC Chiefs and college sports) to Southern Ontario. (Another move which makes little sense. For the most part, people in Southern Ontario are fans of three teams: Toronto, Montreal and Detroit. (My friend Stewart is a Colorado fan and I know a couple Penguins fans and the odd Sabres fan here and there, but most of them belong to the Big Three. Outside of Ottawa nobody cares about the Senators. The Sabres would lose a lot of revenue if Hamilton or Kitchener got a team so that’s not happening. A healthy NHL needs Buffalo for no other reason than to keep Rick Jeanneret employed) There’s only room for one team in Florida and the Lightning have slightly more history than the Panthers (those rats seem like an eon ago) so they’re out too. There are four teams which need to be moved and here’s where they need to go:
a) Move Phoenix back to Winnipeg. It’s time. The Jets were moved because of the lack of a new building and the fact the Canadian dollar was slipping. It was the days before the Salary Cap however, so with the new rules in place making it easy for any team (save Tampa and Toronto) to be able to regularly compete there is no reason at all that a Jets team wouldn’t be healthy. Phoenix failed. The coolest white uniforms need to be brought back.
b) Move Atlanta to Halifax. Canada needs as many teams as possible so the east coast is a reasonable move. It would be a gamble true. But would it be any more of a gamble than expanding to Atlanta in the first place? A city with such a horrid reputation as a sports city that it actually has empty seats during Braves NLDS games? Would this be a bigger gamble than cancelling an entire season in the hopes of fixing the sport to gain a significant TV deal? Would this be a bigger gamble than CBC stupidly thinking they could re create the HNIC theme and that anyone would be impressed with anything that came of it? You get my drift.
c) Give the Florida Panthers to Hartford. I know what you’re thinking, why not just move Carolina back to Hartford? Two reasons, one: Carolina won a Stanley Cup so that counts for something. The fanbase is starting to become regular and say what you want about the Carolina sports scene, but the atmosphere inside the RBC Center during a ‘Canes game is rocking. Secondly and this is totally selfish: Keeping Carolina where they are totally works for my realignment plan. You’ll see why in a few minutes. Florida on the other hand, I mean, have you ever met a Panthers fan? Would anybody miss this team? Would television cameras even record the trucks moving out in the middle of the night like they did when Baltimore moved to Indianpolis in 1984? We could even pretend this expansion never happened like the 1994 CFL USA expansion. Yeah, let’s do that.
d) Here is the King of the moves however. If I were to ask you which NHL team has never ever NOT sold out a hockey game what would you say? This is a team which has never won a Stanley Cup and has won only two playoff series in their history. The most rabid hockey fans in the US reside in Minnesota, and I have absolutely no reason to believe that putting a team in Minneapolis would not only work, but that a St Paul-Minneapolis playoff series would be the biggest thing to happen to that state since Purple Rain came out. The Wild have sold out every game since their inception eight years ago. The Minnesota Golden Gophers are a huge draw. Thousands of kids play pond hockey. Plus the twin cities of St Paul and Minneapolis have the 13th biggest metropolitan area in the US and it has one of the highest standards of living. Sorry Nashville, your new home should be “The land of 10,000 lakes”.
So now that we have the four scourges of the league moved and in new cities we can start discussing realignment. Before the new division line ups are revealed however, it must be said that I racked my brain literally for hours figuring out the best divisional arrangements and then how many games played against each opponent (sad I know). Here we go:
Total # of games: 84 (I did not want to add games; personally I think 82 is too many as it is, but it had to be done)
Division Games: 24 (six against each team)
Conference Games: 20 (four against each team)
Inter-conference Games: 30 (two against each team)
Campbell Conference
East Division
The Campbell East is the first of four monster divisions in this “New NHL”. In it, you have the Montreal Canadiens, Boston Bruins, Carolina Hurricanes, the newly restored Hartford Whalers and the newly moved Halifax NHLers. (You can’t expect me to pick their nickname too, although one comes to mind: Ladies and Gentlemen, the Halifax Seamen) Here you have a division in which four of the teams are from the Northeast, creating geographical rivalries between Montreal and Halifax as well as Boston/Hartford/Halifax. You have one of the best rivalries in the league (Boston/Montreal) as well as reintroducing the Boston/Hartford rivalry. Montreal fans despise playing Carolina because they never ever beat them (that 2002 playoff loss still stings Habs fans) and could you imagine how pumped up the Hartford fans would be to see the Hurricanes playing their new team with the opportunity to stick it to owner Peter Karmanos?? Tell me why this couldn’t and wouldn’t work. Sorry Buffalo and Toronto, you’re out of this division, but trust me, the division you DO get is just as good; if not better.
Central Division
The Campbell Central is an absolutely steeped division (been waiting three years to use that word in that context) made up of three original six teams, the Battle of Ontario and the Battle down the QEW. The Chicago Blackhawks, Detroit Red Wings, Buffalo Sabres, Ottawa Senators and Toronto Maple Leafs comprise this division which not only makes geographic sense but also from a historical standpoint rekindles the type of fierce rivalry NHL fans miss most about the current line ups. Wings/Hawks, Leafs/Sabres, Leafs/Sens, Sens/Sabres, Leafs/Wings: that’s all you need. I know what you’re thinking: This division is totally geared towards Leafs fans. Ok, it might be. But that’s only because they spent 10+ seasons playing against all four of these teams. So what? The most haunting memories of any Leafs fan growing up in the 80s and 90s were spent at the Chicago Stadium, in particular the big bad Chicago Horn. Even though we hated it, we loved it. Go figure. Ask Red Wing or Blackhawk fans if they’d rather see Toronto come to town three times a year instead of Nashville or Columbus. Unless they’re planning on smashing a vase over their head, I bet most would. This would be a very fun division.
West Division
With eight Canadian teams in the “SportsOne’s NHL” it makes sense to keep them all in the same conference, so the remaining four teams comprise the Campbell West with Colorado joining them. (For those of you scoring at home, that’s Calgary, Edmonton, Winnipeg and Vancouver) This division was the easiest by far to figure out. I don’t need to go over why it makes sense from a geographical or marketing standpoint. It would be just as big of a waste of time if I started a discussion on The Hills vs 90210. Just go with me on it. The Campbell West would be a great division.
Wales Conference
East Division
Welcome to our 4th monster division in the SportsOne’s NHL. Are you listening Tampa Bay? You’re going to feel horribly out of place (think Ice Cube in a family comedy…wait a minute), but just go with me ok? There’s nowhere else to put you and you should be happy I even let you stay in my little fake professional hockey league! (That 2004 Stanley Cup pretty much kept you in; horrible personnel moves….horrible) Other than the Lightning, this division has the NY Islanders, NY Rangers, New Jersey Devils and Washington Capitals. (It was really, really hard to keep New Jersey in this league as well but again, three Cups since ‘95) There’s a ton of great rivalries in there. I know I know, Pittsburgh and Philly will be missed. Get over it. They’re in a historical division all their own, along with some old friends from the 1967 Expansion.
Central Division
Perhaps the Wales Central is not chock filled with powerhouse teams like the previous four divisions but hey, sooner or later you run out of teams. Not that this division doesn’t have huge historical significance. As most of you know and not remember because we’re not in our late 40s, when the NHL expanded to 12 teams from the “Original Six” in 1967, the six new teams formed their own division. Amazingly, five of the six teams remain (Oakland is not coming through that door) and four of them are rejoined along with the newest expansion team to make up the Central Division. (There really WAS nowhere to put Columbus; not that it would matter for obvious reasons) Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, St. Louis, and Dallas (obviously formerly the Minnesota North Stars) all joined at the same time so why not put them together again? I’d even make a catch that for every divisional game these teams MUST wear their original jerseys. Is there anything quite as cool as seeing Pittsburgh in their powder blues?
West Division
There’s only one division left and perhaps geographically it makes the least amount of sense but think of it this way: The Minnesota Wild already go out to the west coast at least three times a year to play Vancouver and the three California teams, not to mention Phoenix so its not a stretch to eliminate one trip to BC, add one more to Cali and get rid of the Arizona stop altogether. Behold the Wales West: The Los Angeles Kings, Anaheim Ducks, San Jose Sharks, St Paul Wild and Minneapolis Lakers. (It makes SO much more sense in Minnesota doesn’t it?) There you have it. Six divisions, all with geographical sensibilities and rivalries. What about the playoffs? It’s easy. First, lets look at the divisions in a lateral sense.
East Central West
Boston Chicago Edmonton
Montreal Toronto Calgary
Hartford Detroit Colorado
Carolina Ottawa Winnipeg
Halifax Buffalo Vancouver
NY Rangers St Louis San Jose
NY Islanders Philadelphia St Paul (formerly Minnesota)
Tampa Bay Columbus Los Angeles
New Jersey Pittsburgh Anaheim
Washington Dallas Minneapolis
Vs division: 24
Vs conference: 20
Vs other league: 30
Ok, here’s the playoff rules. It’s still best of seven all the way through, the first AND second place teams in each division qualify automatically and are seeded 1-6. Just because a team wins a crappy division does not guarantee a Top 3 seed. All too often we hear people complain about certain teams in the current Southeast division getting a top seed just because they won their garbage division. (Nobody ever seems to point out that two of the last four Stanley Cup winners came from that division however)
Next, the best two remaining teams get in. They could be the two best third place teams in two divisions or the 3rd and 4th place teams in one division. Either way, they’re seeded 7-8. Another change and this is one hockey purists will hate, but it would make hockey playoff pools relevant again: No re-seeding after each round. If the No 8 team knocks off the No 1 seed 4-2 in round one, the 4-5 winner still gets to play the No 8 seed. Just like in the NCAA tournament, sometimes you get lucky.
So there you go. The Dream NHL. Move some teams around to better markets, bring back the rivalries of the 70s and 80s and admit that only dinosaurs care about the Leafs/Habs “rivalry” anymore. Then we can move onto slaying the commish. Bring on the hot oil! It’s something we can build on together. Yes we can. Yes we can. Happy new year everyone. The SportsOne is back.